Rekey when
- The lock is sound and you like it.
- You just need old keys to stop working.
- You want several doors on one key.
Replace when
- The lock is worn, loose or corroded.
- You want a keypad or smart lock.
- A break-in damaged it.
- The hardware is cheap and you want better.
Do not forget the door
- A strong lock in a weak frame is little use.
- Check the strike plate and the screws.
Cost thinking
- Rekeying costs less per lock when the hardware stays.
- With many locks, the gap narrows; ask for both prices.
A quick way to decide
If the lock works smoothly, the finish is sound and you only worry about who has keys, rekeying is normally enough. If the lock sticks, the bolt drags, the handle is loose or the finish has failed, replace it. If you want a new feature such as a keypad or a higher grade of deadbolt, replace it.
Common situations in Scarborough
A tenant moving into a rental with decent hardware: rekey. A homeowner whose old deadbolt has been temperamental for years: replace. A landlord turning over a townhouse: rekey the entry and patio doors and log the new keys. A business with staff turnover: consider a restricted or master-key system.
What the technician should tell you
Ask for the reason behind the recommendation and the price of each option. A good technician can explain in a sentence why rekeying is or is not enough. Ask about the strike and frame at the same time, because a strong lock on a weak frame gives little protection. See rental turnover key plan.
Need a locksmith? See our emergency locksmith and pricing and process pages.